FAA is calling for repetitive inspections and eventual replacement of Engine Components Inc. (ECi) and Airmotive Engineering “Titan” cylinders found on 6,000 Continental 520 and 550 model reciprocating engines at a cost that could reach $82.6 million.
ECi objected to the proposal, saying the required actions “will degrade safety, not improve it” by requiring thousands of premature top overhauls. “Industry experience shows that there is a substantial risk of catastrophic engine failure following such top overhauls,” ECi says.
FAA says the proposed airworthiness directive, issued Aug. 12, stems from investigations into numerous reports of cylinder head-to-barrel separations and cracked and leaking aluminum cylinder heads on the affected assemblies.
Research discovered two “independent failure modes” that cause the cylinder head separations, but the root cause of those failures cannot be definitively pinpointed, the agency says. One failure mode involves cracking that stems from the internal dome radius of the cylinder head, and the second involves cracking at the cylinder head-to-barrel threads.
The proposal follows a series of meetings and correspondence between, ECi, Airmotive Engineering Corp. (an ECi affiliate company which had been the production approval holder for Titan assemblies), NTSB and FAA, considering ramifications of potential requirements and alternatives, FAA maintains.
“Knowing the likely impact that compliance with the AD will have upon the owners and operators, a detailed review was performed to consider all aspects of the information provided by Airmotive Engineering Corp.,” FAA says. But it adds that after conducting a risk assessment, “we concluded that proceeding with this proposed AD to correct the unsafe condition was appropriate.”
Concern For Years
FAA, the NTSB and industry have grappled with problems of cracked cylinder heads for years. FAA has issued a series of ADs, and the NTSB, which has focused on assembly failures since 2000, last year issued a recommendation for inspection and replacement of certain ECi assemblies.
FAA and NTSB in 2005 formed a task force to study failure of cylinder heads in general. That task force made several site visits, including to ECi to discuss manufacturing processes.