Pratt Dismisses CFM Leap's Superiority Claims Regarding GTF

By Graham Warwick
Source: AWIN First
June 17, 2013
Credit: Pratt & Whitney

With 5,000 hr. and 13,000 cycles on PW1000G test engines, 10% them in flight, Pratt & Whitney (P&W) is dismissing claims by rival CFM that its engine can beat the geared turbofan (GTF) on fuel burn and maintenance costs.

Pointing out that CFM’s Leap-1A engine for the Airbus A320NEO will not run until the fall, P&W President David Hess says “our NEO engine is flying and, in the most recent configuration, the fuel-burn numbers are half a percent better than predictions.”

Arguing “that’s a real engine, real testing and real data,” he says “there is no way on fuel burn and no way on maintenance cost that they can get the NPV [net present value] advantage they are claiming . . . unless they defy the laws of physics.”

CFM executive vice president Chaker Chahrour said here on Saturday that the Leap-1A will provide 1% better specific fuel consumption (sfc) than the PW1100G on the A320NEO, plus another 1% over the life of the engine as a result of better performance retention.

The General Electric/Snecma joint venture is claiming a $4 million per aircraft NPV advantage, half from lower fuel burn and half from lower maintenance costs—the latter based largely based on CFM’s estimates for costs related to the PW1100G’s gearbox.

But Hess says P&W’s fan-drive gearbox will not need maintenance until the engine’s second shop visit, “and the engine will never come in for a gearbox.” Additionally, 75-80% of sales agreements include per-hour maintenance agreements under which Pratt is “guaranteeing the cost to airlines.”

“We will be on our weight and fuel-burn guarantee at entry into service, which has not happened for some time in their industry,” he says. “And we seem pretty confident on the maintenance data. We are very confident in our assertions and are guaranteeing them in contracts.”

Pratt has more than 3,500 PW1000G-series engine on order and option and Hess expects to add more over the course of the air show. The GTF family has five applications: Bombardier CSeries, Mitsubishi Regional Jet (MRJ), A320NEO, Irkut MS-21 and now Embraer’s second-generation E-Jet.

The next-generation version of the Embraer 175 will use a derivative of the MRJ’s 56-in.-fan, the 15,000-17,000-lb.-thrust PW1200G, while the larger members of the new E-Jet family will use a derivative of the CSeries’ 73-in.-fan, the 21,000-23,000-lb.-thrust PW1500G, he says.

Comments On Articles